This is a debate we often have in my house. It is the 'rough trade' versus the 'beautiful bit of fluff' debate. (Not wanting to objectify the actors of course! .) My girlfriend is definately a Legolas devotee. I like the more grungy Aragon (but could swing the other way). I thought about including a few more characters in the poll (e.g. Gollum??) or some of the female characters, but am interested more in the gay or bi guy and straight or bi female perspective... and this boils down to Aragon versus Legolas, I believe. Correct me if I'm wrong of course. Straight guys are more than welcome to tick the 'other' box and include an opinion below.