A couple whom my girlfriend and I hooked up 3 years ago is arguing back and forth now. She made out with a guy who wasn't exactly her boyfriend Andrew while she was completely trashed. She was so remorseful over the entire thing, and believes it was a tremendous mistake that will never be repeated again because she has stopped drinking. She believes it's okay that she continues to talk to the guy she made out with. She claims they both talked about it, realized it was wrong in every way possible, and wants to just lock it in the past and move on with life with her boyfriend Andrew and her friend Mark. Would you see this to be okay? I mean in reality, Andrew can't do shit but trust her, besides telling her "hey I really don't like you talking to him." But what would you think? Would this be okay, especially if both of them demonstrated shame and vowed that it was a huge mistake that won't be repeated? I don't really know what to tell him, but one side of me is like "dude you can't control her" and yet another one is like "what the hell?"